I know I might have lead you to believe that Michael actually made these cookies, because, you know, I called this post 'Michael Cooks.'
He didn't.
But I'm all Trim Healthy Mama and stuff, and have all these new blog followers who came here for the THM recipes and whatnot, and so making cookies out of white sugar doesn't sound AT ALL like something *I would do. You KNOW me. You can trust me to ONLY make healthy stuff.
{Mostly.}
So that's why, if you see something not so healthy here, it had to have been Michael's idea. I did make these for him, after all. I mean, no... you can't prove I made these, and if I would have made these, hypothetically, they would have been for Michael. So, Michael cooks. The end. Stop making a big deal out of it. Gosh.

But I'll be honest... I do love peanut butter. ALLLL things peanut butter. It was a wicked craving during my first pregnancy in 2001, and its never faded. TCBY Peanut Butter Shakes? OOOOOhhhhh baby. Braum's Peanut Butter Cup Ice Cream? YES. And of course Nutter Butters.
Of COURSE homemade is ALWAYS better. They taste better. There are no chemicals or preservatives. They aren't five bucks for a measly package that's gone in one blink.
If you're a peanut butter lover like me, you've GOTTA try these.
Unless, of course, you're a Trim Healthy Mama, and then you're gonna want to stop reading right about now and come back after I wrestle control of this blog back from Michael and his sinful recipes.
Start with a good peanut butter cookie recipe. I LOVE this one, because it makes SOFT cookies. That's on account of the four sticks of butter.
Blame Michael.
I like to use my Pampered Chef scoop so all the cookies will be uniform.
And of course one of the unchangeable laws of the universe is that peanut butter cookies MUST have a criss-cross design pressed into the top with the tines of a fork. Look, I don't make the rules.
These cookies are delicious enough in and of themselves.
Peanut buttery, buttery goodness. Sweet, and slightly salty.
Bake them a short time so they don't get too hard. Soft cookies are the best. Which is the main reason these are leaps and bounds better than store-bought.
Beautiful... Michael took this picture below. He's really, really good at food photography. That, and thinking up really sinful cookies...
Then there's this FILLING.
Yes, please. Are you kidding me? Shut the front door. I am literally in love with this. I am SOOOO doing this. Nom nom nom.
Oh no. WHAT HAPPENED?! I'm sorry. I just got drunk on this peanut butter filling and spewed all of the most Annoying and Overused Pinterest Phrases, RIGHT THERE IN ONE PARAGRAPH.
PLEASE forgive me. It won't happen again.
Ahem.
But this filling... use your Pampered Chef Easy Accent Decorator to pipe it in there between two cookies.
And there you have it. I got three marriage proposals from Michael's coworkers the day I sent these to his work. THREE! Feeling lonely? Stock up on some butter and make these today.
Click here for these cookies on Pinterest.
Homemade Nutter Butter Cookies
Ingredients
2 Sticks (1 cup) butter, softened
1 cup peanut butter (I like crunchy for the cookies)
1 cup sugar
1 cup brown sugar, packed
2 eggs
2 tsp vanilla
2 1/2 cups flour
1 tsp baking soda
1 tsp baking powder (make sure it doesn't have aluminum, so your cookies will be healthy...)
1 tsp sea salt (I like
Real Salt)
Filling
2 Sticks (1 cup) butter, softened
1 cup peanut butter (creamy works best for filling)
4 cups (1 box) powdered sugar
1 tsp sea salt
2-3 tablespoons milk
Directions
For the cookies... Preheat oven to 350*, then...
1. IN a large mixer bowl, cream together butter, peanut butter, and sugars until light and fluffy, about two minutes.
2. Add eggs and vanilla and mix well.
3. In a small mixer bowl, stir together your dry ingredients: flour, baking soda, baking powder, and salt. Add this to your butter mixture and mix well.
4. Using a scoop or two teaspoons, form dough into 1-inch balls and place them on a baking stone (or cookie sheet) 2 inches apart. Using a fork, press down slightly to make a criss-cross pattern; I found that rocking the fork back and forth works best since this dough is so buttery.
5. Bake 10 minutes or until edges are slightly golden; remove from oven and allow to cool on your stone until cookies flatten themselves slightly (they'll be puffy when you pull them from the oven).
6. Transfer to a wire rack and allow to cool completely.
Meanwhile, make the filling:
7. IN a large mixer bowl cream together butter and peanut butter until smooth.
8. SLOWLY add powdered sugar, 1/2 cup at a time, unless you want to wear it; add your salt. Slowly add milk until your frosting is a spreadable consistency.
9. Spread a tablespoon or two of filling onto the bottom of one cookie, then press another cookie to form a sandwich.
10. Pick out your wedding dress, baby. The proposals are gonna be rolling in.